The government’s proposed income insurance scheme is being described as a “social insurance” scheme. What does that mean, and why is the characterisation important for how you think about the scheme and how it could be funded?
Read More
Vaccine mandates should not be seen as anything other than a severe step responding to a dire situation. There may well be good reason for them, but before deciding that we need to honestly recognise how severe an imposition they are.
Read More
The government is introducing a vaccine mandate which will cover much of the work force. There’s a hole: an unclear provision for exemptions is probably wider in scope that the Ministry of Health seems to think.
Read More
As the Government moves to make vaccination compulsory in more and more situations, it should learn from the problems associated with the already existing mask mandate.
Read More
The Government plans to expand ACC to cover some birth injuries. That’s good. But it’s doing it in a daft way.
Read More
In trying to defend their decision not to make a special extension of the ACC scheme to include victims of the mosque attacks, the government seems to be pushing a narrative that the ACC scheme is about physical injuries. I have two objections to this. First, it’s ahistorical. Second, the physical/mental divide is dubious and problematic.
Read More
WorkSafe has charged the Government’s volcano watchdog, GNS Science, as one of the thirteen parties in relation to the Whakaari/White Island eruption. We don’t yet know why. But can they really be guilty of not sciencing properly?
Read More
Labour’s (or, at least, Jacinda Ardern’s) decision to rule out all but a minimal increase to the top tax rate puts real constraints on the social policy changes it can make. But there’s one policy area where progressive reform remains on the table and so “transformation” is still possible.
Read More
Should returning New Zealanders be charged for the time they must spend in isolation? That turns out to be a really tricky question to answer.
Read More
Is it really true that the High Court is (partly) to blame for the recent decision to allow COVID-19 infected travellers out of quarantine? No. No it isn’t.
Read More
Was Simon Bridges’ false claim that average wage earners pay 33% in tax a mistake, or a clever double dog whistle … and if the latter, what can be done about it?
Read More
The Whakaari / White Island tragedy raises issues of risk, harm and responsibility, and whether our ACC scheme properly deals with these.
Read More
You commit the “no true Kiwi” fallacy by insisting that bigotry isn’t the real Kiwi way. Doing so isn’t just flawed reasoning, it ignores those for whom bigotry is a very real part of their lives. Instead: listen, re-examine, aspire, and be a helper.
Read More
The Government has created 2 new criminal offences aimed at cattle rustling. These have been generally well received. But there are reasons to be concerned, both about the laws themselves, and about the process by which they were made. This post focuses on what’s concerning about that, and is followed by another questioning the changes themselves.
Read More
In New Zealand, freedom of speech doesn't have to be, and currently isn't, exclusively concerned with preventing the state from punishing people for speech. Nevertheless, people sometimes claim that freedom of speech has to take on that narrow meaning.
Read More
An Attorney-General's Report that says a Government-supported Bill is an unjustifiable restriction on freedom of expression, claims of a ban on the phrase "ballet teacher", none of which turns out to be that exciting after all (probably).
Read More
The makers of app LegalFling claim it creates a "legally binding contract" for sex that can result in remedies for breach, including enforcement of penalty clauses. I think it doesn't.
Read More
The family of Blessie Gotingco, who was murdered by an offender just out of prison, are crowdfunding with a view to a possible civil claim. The litigation following an earlier similar incident suggests that there are some pretty big legal obstacles in the way of a successful claim.
Read More
Jamie Whyte claims that poverty statistics based on relative measures of poverty are misleading. I explain why his argument is unpersuasive.
Read More
The Government is seeking to retrospectively change the law to match the Ministry of Social Welfare's practice. Retrospective legislation is bad generally, and very bad in this case.
Read More